Advertisement
Advertisement
Read Next
Fall Sunsets Assignment Winner Saradwata Sarkar
Congratulations to Saradwata Sarkar for...Fujifilm GFX100S: Compact, More Affordable Medium Format
Fujifilm today introduced the GFX100S...Photo Of The Day By Max Foster
Today’s Photo Of The Day is...Photo Of The Day By Ross Stone
Today’s Photo Of The Day is...Advertisement
Featured Articles
Read More
Challenge Accepted
Tips and techniques for getting started in adventure sports photography.
Read More
How To Plan A Milky Way Photo Shoot
Tips for choosing locations, timing and creative approaches to photographing the Milky Way above the landscape for incredible nighttime photos.
To access this content, you must purchase Outdoor Photographer Membership.
Read More
Wildlife Photography Gear On A Budget
While you can photograph wildlife with any camera and lens, some gear makes doing so easier and more productive.
Read More
Upper Bond Falls
Bond Falls State Park, Michigan.
To access this content, you must purchase Outdoor Photographer Membership.
Read More
Choosing A Lens Set For Nature Photography
When putting together a lens kit for outdoor photography, there are three basic ways to do it.
Read More
How To Use Histograms
For precise exposures that best capture a scene’s dynamic range, ignore what the image preview looks like and rely on the histogram.
To access this content, you must purchase Outdoor Photographer Membership.
Creativity and Copying
I took this a decade ago (on Velvia!) and have rarely published it, largely because I felt it was essentially derivative, e.g. a conceptual copy of Tom’s image. I never really felt that this was my own original creation, but essentially a copy. Yes, it represented a personal challenge – the challenge of coordinating timing, light and technique to capture a “decisive moment.” And it is substantially different from Tom’s image. But it was not something essentially new. No one can look at my picture and not think of his, or of his priority.
The issue, then, is this. Is a “copy” of a legendary photograph an homage, plagiarism…or a legitimate exercise of creativity? You will likely find as many views on this subject as there are people posting comments online (and I look forward to seeing more here). Some consider the idea of “copying” a classic Galen Rowell photo (like “Sunset on Horsetail Falls” – a picture I consider so perfect as to repel improvement) simply a learning experience, much as fine artists may copy the work of the Great Masters to learn something about their technique. I don’t fully buy this argument, since it seems to me that there are vast numbers of other subjects in which you can test your mastery of depth-of-field or exposure other than by trying to replicate a well-known David Muench landscape.
However, in discussing this subject with a friend of mine, a talented and hard-working amateur photographer, I gained another point of view. In his opinion, this issue is directly linked to the photograph’s end use. As an amateur shooting for his own pleasure and for a “hang-on-the-wall” image, there is absolutely nothing wrong with trying to capture an icon for himself. It is an excuse to chase, not just a picture, but a beautiful location, or a beautiful moment, in nature.
The problem, then, is when photographers try to pass these images as original creations and offer them for sale, as prints or in publication, knowing they are entirely based on someone else’s original work. We would not condone copying a chapter from someone else’s novel – so why do we give photographers a pass that slavishly copy someone else’s picture? It seems unethical, but more than anything ,it lacks creativity. And in a creative endeavor like photography this, in the end, is the greatest crime.
In the end, the best, most exciting images will continue to push visual boundaries, to show viewers something new and exciting and different. Yes, this is getting more difficult than ever, with the vast numbers of photographers prowling our parks and refuges. But I cannot help but think that there are still plenty of thrilling images still to be taken, pictures that show us something, or somewhere, we have never seen.
I welcome your thoughts on this subject.